Go to Top


Five generations of Sitterleys and three generations of Vandervoorts have all enjoyed living in the Lancaster area. 

The first two generations of Sitterleys were farmers.

Kermit Sitterley attended a one room school house in Bloom township, graduated from Canal Winchester High school and attended college and law school at The Ohio State University. Kermit Sitterley’s father-in-law, Ray E. Hummel, was in the second graduating class from Ohio State Law School in 1902, practicing in Carroll, Ohio and serving in the Ohio House of Representatives.

Kermit C. Sitterley 1910-2004

Kermit C. Sitterley

Following his 1933 graduation from law school, Kermit joined Judge Brooks Shell to found a law practice in Lancaster. Judge Shell, who had recently stepped off the Fairfield County Common Pleas bench, lived only a short while thereafter. Kermit established an office in the corner of what was then the Equitable Building, (currently Chase), where Sitterley, Vandervoort, & Davis Ltd currently has a suite of offices. During World War II, from 1943 to 1945, Kermit maintained his practice in Lancaster while serving as a Naval Officer in Washington, D.C.. For 65 years, Kermit practiced in Lancaster, working for clients throughout Fairfield County and the surrounding areas. Kermit spent part of this time on his own and part of the time associated with other local attorneys.

In 1973, Kermit invited his son, William J. Sitterley, and his son-in-law, Peter M. Vandervoort, to become partners with him. Craig M. Vandervoort joined the firm in 1992, followed by Jeffrey K. Vandervoort in 1999 and Jennifer H. Sitterley Baum in 2010. The firm was happy to announce the addition of Judy Edwards as Of Counsel in 2013.